Addressing Jail Overcrowding through Electronic Tracking of Undertrials

Published On:

India's prison system faces critical challenges due to overcrowding, with a majority of inmates being undertrials awaiting trial or bail. This overcrowding strains prison infrastructure and affects the well-being of inmates and their families. To address this, the Supreme Court’s Centre for Research and Planning has recommended the use of electronic tracking devices for undertrial prisoners as a possible solution to reduce prison overcrowding.

Overcrowding in Prisons

As of December 31, 2022, Indian jails had an occupancy rate of 131%, with 5,73,220 inmates against a total capacity of 4,36,266. Out of this population, approximately 4,34,302 inmates were undertrials, accounting for around 76% of the prison population. This high occupancy rate highlights the pressing need for prison reform and alternatives to incarceration.

Proposal for Electronic Tracking

The proposed solution involves using electronic tracking devices for undertrial prisoners who meet specific criteria for release on bail or parole. These devices could help monitor and track the movements of released individuals, thus easing prison congestion without compromising public safety. Similar measures have been successfully implemented in countries like the United States, Canada, the United Kingdom, Malaysia, and Australia.

Legal Precedents and Support for Reform

Recent court rulings have supported alternative approaches for decongesting prisons, with conditional bail being granted in some cases for individuals willing to undergo tracking. The Centre for Research and Planning has highlighted that electronic tracking could be tested on low-risk undertrials and later expanded based on the results. The Ministry of Home Affairs has also been involved in examining the feasibility of this initiative.

Advantages of Electronic Tracking

The primary benefits of electronic tracking include reducing overcrowding, decreasing stress for inmates and their families, and preventing the isolation of undertrials from society. Additionally, electronic tracking may enhance rehabilitation by allowing selected undertrials to reintegrate gradually with society, lowering the psychological and social impact of incarceration.

Challenges and Concerns

While the proposal offers advantages, concerns remain over potential misuse and privacy violations. Ensuring the proper usage of these devices and defining clear guidelines are crucial for safeguarding the rights of individuals under electronic surveillance. There is also a need for a robust legal framework to address issues related to consent, misuse, and the impact on civil liberties.

Safeguards and Future Steps

To implement electronic tracking successfully, it is essential to establish comprehensive safeguards to prevent misuse and protect individual rights. The Centre for Research and Planning suggests that the tracking system should undergo rigorous testing, and the judiciary should have oversight over the usage of electronic monitoring. This approach may serve as a foundation for broader prison reforms, addressing overcrowding and contributing to a more effective and humane criminal justice system.