Industrial Accidents

Published On:

Why in News?

Recently, an explosion at a chemical plant in Thane, Maharashtra, killed 11 people. Industrial accidents like this are a big problem for factories in India and around the world.

What are the Key Factors Contributing to Industrial Accidents in India?

Problems in the Chemical Industry:

1. Inadequate Regulation and Monitoring:

• There are too many overlapping regulations (15 Acts and 19 rules) without a unified approach for the chemical industry.
• This causes confusion and weakens safety oversight and enforcement.

2. Lack of a Comprehensive Chemical Risk Database**:

• There is no central database on industrial chemicals and their risks.
• This makes it difficult to assess hazards and develop safety protocols.

3. Insufficient Worker Training and Awareness:

• Untrained, temporary workers often operate boilers without proper safety and emergency training.
• This leads to confusion and increased risks during accidents, especially with hazardous chemicals.

4. Poor Investment in Worker Safety:

• Some industries cut costs by neglecting safety equipment and infrastructure like proper ventilation and fire safety.
• An IIT Kanpur study in 2023 emphasized the need for more investment in worker safety to reduce accidents.

5. Lack of Maintenance:

• The Visakhapatnam gas leak involving benzimidazole highlighted concerns about maintenance and operations.
• In the Neyveli incident, a boiler unexpectedly exploded during maintenance, even though it was not operational and only involved a furnace and steam production.

What are the Consequences of Such Industrial and Chemical Accidents?

• Industrial accidents cause a lot of deaths and injuries. For example, an explosion at a chemical factory in Thane killed 11 people.
• Chemical leaks, explosions, and bad waste disposal hurt the environment a lot. They make the air, water, and soil dirty. For instance, the Bhopal Gas Tragedy in 1984 was awful. A gas leak from a Union Carbide plant killed thousands and made many others sick.
• Fixing things after accidents costs a ton of money. Companies have to pay to repair buildings, help victims' families, and treat injured workers. According to a study by the US Environmental Protection Agency, accidents can also lower property values in nearby areas by 5-7%, which hurts the local economy.
• Industrial accidents can leave people with deep emotional scars. Survivors, witnesses, and victims' families can suffer from anxiety, depression, and PTSD.
• When accidents happen often, people stop trusting the government and companies to keep them safe. They get scared and might fight against new industrial projects.

What are the Legal Safeguards against Chemical/Industrial Disasters?

• The Sendai Framework for Disaster Risk Reduction (2015-2030) aims to lessen the impact of disasters worldwide. The UN Convention on the Transboundary Effects of Industrial Accidents (1992) helps countries work together to prevent and handle industrial accidents. It encourages sharing information, planning for emergencies, and supporting each other during crises.
• The Flexible Framework for Accident Prevention and Preparedness (CAPP) (2006) by UNEP helps countries, especially developing ones, create programs to prevent and prepare for chemical accidents. It gives guidance tailored to each country's needs.
• The OECD Programme on Chemical Accidents (1990) focuses on preventing accidents by sharing information and promoting best practices in chemical safety.
• In India, laws like the Bhopal Gas Leak (Processing of Claims) Act, 1985, the Environment Protection Act, 1986 (EPA), and the Public Liability Insurance Act, 1991 (PLIA) are crucial. The PLIA mandates insurance for industries dealing with hazardous substances, providing financial help to those affected by accidents involving these substances.
• The National Environment Appellate Authority Act, 1997, sets up the National Environment Appellate Authority (NEAA). It hears appeals regarding restrictions on certain industrial activities under the EPA, ensuring a fair process.
• The Hazardous Waste (Management Handling and Transboundary Movement) Rules, 1989, require industries to identify accident risks, take preventive measures, and report hazards to the authorities.
• The National Disaster Management Authority (NDMA) has issued guidelines on Chemical Disaster Management. These give directions to various authorities for making detailed disaster management plans.
• Other laws like the Factories Act, 1948, and the Insecticides Act, 1968, also contribute to ensuring industrial safety.

Way Forward

• Creating a strong regulatory framework is crucial. The International Labour Organization (ILO) suggests having clear national rules and assigning different government agencies specific roles to enforce safety regulations.
• According to the World Bank in 2018, having strict regulations on chemical safety is vital for preventing chemical accidents.
• Improving monitoring and enforcement is essential. A study by IIM Ahmedabad in 2020 blames weak enforcement for India's industrial accidents. They suggest imposing stricter penalties and conducting more frequent inspections by qualified personnel.
• It's important to have a central database to document risks related to industrial chemicals, as highlighted by the Bhopal Gas Tragedy of 1984. This helps in understanding and managing these risks effectively.
• The OECD promotes the Global Harmonized System of Classification and Labelling of Chemicals (GHS), which provides a standard way to classify chemicals, helping in better risk assessments.
• Investing in worker training is crucial. A 2017 study by the National Safety Council of India (NSCI) found that many accidents happen because workers aren't aware of safety protocols. NSCI recommends comprehensive training programs for all staff levels.
• Encouraging industries to adopt environmentally friendly technologies (ESTs) is important. These technologies reduce the use of hazardous materials, improve waste management, and lower the risk of accidents, as suggested by the UNEP.
• Providing incentives and support for upgrading safety measures can motivate companies to improve safety. This could include offering financial aid such as tax breaks or subsidies for upgrading infrastructure and adopting new technologies.

Conclusion

The frequent industrial accidents in India highlight the pressing need to fill regulatory and knowledge gaps in the country's industrial sector. To tackle this issue, both the government and industry stakeholders must collaborate closely, taking a comprehensive and forward-thinking approach. By doing so, India can progress towards safer and more sustainable industrial development.

Sympatric Speciation

Why in News?

A new study from IIT Bombay talks about how new species can develop even when they live in the same area. This goes against the old idea that new species only form when groups of animals are separated by geography.

What is Sympatric Speciation?

• Speciation is when a group of animals or plants becomes different from the rest of their species. Sympatric speciation happens when new species develop in the same place where their ancestors lived.
• Allopatric speciation, on the other hand, is when new species form because some animals or plants get separated from the rest of their species by something like a river, mountain, or canyon. They end up living in different places and gradually become different from each other.
• For example, when the Grand Canyon formed, it split a group of squirrels into two separate populations. Over time, these squirrels changed so much that now there are different types of squirrels living on the north and south sides of the canyon.
• But birds and other animals that could fly or move easily across the canyon didn't get split into separate groups. They could still mate with each other and didn't become different species.

What are the Key Highlights of the Study?

The study looked at three important things: disruptive selection, sexual selection, and genetic architecture, by simulating a population of birds.

• Disruptive Selection: This is when animals with different traits do better than those with average traits because of how resources are spread out. For example, birds with small beaks might be better at getting nuts, while those with longer beaks might be better at getting nectar from flowers. The study found that this kind of selection can split a population even if they all live in the same place.
• Sexual Selection: This is when animals pick mates based on certain traits. The study found that if birds pick mates based on traits that help them get resources, like beak size for getting food, it can lead to new species forming. But if they pick mates based on things like feather color, it doesn't lead to new species. Also, picking mates based on specific traits might mean their babies aren't as healthy.
• Genetic Architecture: This means how genes influence traits. Even if the selection for traits isn't very strong, if the genes allow for those traits to change, new species can still happen. For example, even if the birds don't have strong reasons to change their beak size, if their genes make it easy to change, new species can still develop.

India in Trade Deficit with Top Trading Partners

Why in News?

Recent official data reveals that India had a trade deficit with 9 out of its top 10 trading partners during the 2023-24 period. This means that India imported more goods and services from these countries than it exported to them.

What is the Current Status of India’s Trade Deficit?

• In the last fiscal year, India's overall trade deficit decreased to $238.3 billion from $264.9 billion in the previous year. However, the trade deficit with China, Russia, South Korea, and Hong Kong increased compared to the year before. On the other hand, the trade gap with the UAE, Saudi Arabia, Russia, Indonesia, and Iraq decreased.
• China became India's biggest trading partner in 2023-24, with a total trade of $118.4 billion, surpassing the US. However, the US held the top position in trade with India in the previous two fiscal years. India had a trade surplus of $36.74 billion with the US in 2023-24, as well as with the UK, Belgium, Italy, France, and Bangladesh.
• India has free trade agreements with four of its top trading partners: Singapore, the UAE, South Korea, and Indonesia (as part of the Asian bloc).

What are the Reasons Behind India’s Trade Deficit?

• India faces challenges due to its heavy reliance on energy imports, particularly crude oil, which accounts for more than 85% of its needs. Fluctuations in global oil prices can greatly affect India's trade deficit.
• Certain Indian industries, such as pharmaceuticals and semiconductors, heavily depend on imported raw materials and intermediates. This reliance on imports increases the value of imports and contributes to the trade deficit. For example, the pharmaceutical sector imports a significant amount of Active Pharmaceutical Ingredients (APIs) from China.
• Additionally, India struggles to export enough manufactured goods to balance its imports. Factors such as lower manufacturing capabilities and competitiveness in the global market compared to countries like China and the US contribute to this imbalance.

What are the Key Impacts of the Trade Deficit on the Indian Economy?

Benefits:

1. A trade deficit isn't necessarily negative if it involves importing raw materials or intermediary products, as it can boost manufacturing and exports.

2. In the short term, a trade deficit ensures a wider variety of goods and services are available to citizens, improving living standards by offering more choices.

3. A trade deficit can lead to currency depreciation, making Indian exports more competitive globally due to lower prices.

4. In some cases, a trade deficit can drive domestic businesses to innovate and become more efficient to compete with imported goods. This can create jobs in export-oriented sectors like packaging, shipping, and logistics.

Challenges:

1. Over-reliance on imports can hinder domestic innovation and production in certain sectors, reducing the availability of domestically produced goods.

2. A large trade deficit, especially in sectors with significant import penetration, can lead to job losses in related industries.

3. For instance, cheap textile imports from Bangladesh have caused some Indian industries to close down, resulting in job losses.

4. A persistent trade deficit can weaken the value of the rupee, making imports even pricier.

5. Reduced exports can lower government revenue from export duties, impacting funding for social programs and infrastructure development.

6. To finance a trade deficit, India may need to borrow from foreign sources, increasing external debt and interest payments.

7. This could deplete forex reserves further and signal economic instability to investors, leading to reduced foreign investment.

What Measures can be taken to Control the Trade Deficit?

Trade Agreements:

Negotiating and implementing Free Trade Agreements (FTAs) with key partners can lower tariffs and other barriers for Indian exports, boosting their competitiveness abroad. For instance, the India-UAE CEPA aims to reduce tariffs on over 80% of bilateral trade, potentially benefiting exports of Indian textiles, pharmaceuticals, and agricultural products.

Improving Export Infrastructure:

Investing in infrastructure development, like upgrading ports, roads, and logistics networks, can make the export process smoother and lower transportation costs.

Import Substitution:

Encouraging the use of domestic substitutes for imported products through public procurement policies and campaigns promoting locally made goods can reduce reliance on imports. For example, promoting the use of domestically produced steel in government infrastructure projects can boost the domestic steel industry.

Rationalizing Imports:

Analyzing import data can help identify non-essential or luxury goods that could be substituted with domestically produced alternatives. For instance, the government could discourage the import of certain electronic items through higher tariffs, prompting consumers to choose domestically produced options.

Skilling the Workforce:

Investing in skill development programs can create a workforce with the expertise needed for modern industries, enhancing domestic production capabilities and reducing reliance on imports.

Managing Currency and Debt Levels:

The Reserve Bank of India (RBI) should manage the rupee's exchange rate effectively, aiming for a balance that promotes exports without causing excessive depreciation. Additionally, the government should focus on fiscal consolidation to reduce its debt burden, creating a more stable economic environment for domestic industries to thrive.

Conclusion

Absolutely, addressing the trade deficit and promoting sustainable economic growth requires a tailored approach. There's no universal solution because the effectiveness of measures depends on factors like trade partners, types of imports and exports, and global economic conditions. The Indian government must evaluate the situation carefully and implement a mix of strategies to tackle the trade deficit effectively and foster long-term economic development.